Ethical Leadership Under Pressure: Inside Week 8 of the Walton MBA Leadership Course

A backpacked hiker talks with an elderly man wrapped in orange on a rocky mountain trail at sunrise, above cloud-filled valleys and snowy peaks.
October 11 , 2026  |  By Adam Stoverink

Share this via:

This article was originally published on LinkedIn.

Imagine you’re high in the Himalayas, with a limited window to cross a mountain pass safely. Some members of your group are struggling with the altitude. Along the way, you encounter a barefoot, nearly naked holy man suffering from hypothermia.

What responsibility do you have to get him to safety? Would you help him if it meant sacrificing your own goal?

Week 8 of our Walton MBA – University of Arkansas leadership course focused on ethical leadership. Matt Waller and I explored how a variety of pressures can influence our decisions when confronted with an ethical dilemma.

The scenario on the mountain is a modern day version of the biblical Parable of the Good Samaritan. In that story, a man is robbed, beaten, and left injured beside the road. A priest and a Levite each pass him by. A Samaritan stops, tends to his wounds, takes him to an inn, and pays for his care.

The encounter on the mountain happened to Bowen McCoy while he was on sabbatical from his work at Morgan Stanley. His published account, The Parable of the Sadhu, was one of our class readings for the week. In it, Bowen explores how a group responds to a similar need while facing a demanding goal and risks to its own members.

What would you do if you found yourself on that mountain faced with a man in need of help?

We began the class by asking our MBA students the following: imagine it’s your first week at a new job. You’re excited to be assigned to the largest and most important client. You have an update about a possible product launch due to that client in ten minutes. An important test is still unfinished. Your manager drops in your office and asks you to report the project as complete because the team expects to finish testing tomorrow morning. You know the client will use your update to decide whether to approve the launch.

What would you do?

We then added another source of pressure. Imagine that your teammates routinely report unfinished work as complete. When you ask about it at lunch, someone says, “It’s really no big deal. We do it all the time.” The rest of the team nods their heads in agreement.

What would you do?

Using Milgram’s obedience research and the Asch social conformity experiments, we examined the pressure we all feel to comply with authority and go along with a group. We also discussed ethical fading, which occurs when a deadline or performance target absorbs so much attention that the ethical implications of a decision slip out of view.

The Good Samaritan connection extends to a Princeton study published in 1973. John Darley and Daniel Batson asked students at Princeton Theological Seminary to prepare a short talk on either the Good Samaritan or career opportunities for seminary graduates. The students then walked to another building to deliver it. Along the way, they encountered a man slumped in a doorway, coughing and groaning. He was part of the experiment. You might think that everyone who was preparing to speak about the Good Samaritan would stop and help this man. But only 53% did. Some students even stepped over the man on their way to discuss the parable.

This relatively low percentage of helpers was partially due to another feature of the study. Before they left the first building, some were told they had a few minutes to spare. Others were told they were already late and needed to hurry. Among those given time to spare, 63% offered help. Among those told they were late, only 10% offered help. Time pressure was the dominant factor shaping the students’ decision.

I see a similar pressure in the mountain climbers’ urgency and our client update scenario. At work, we’re constantly trying to make the next meeting, meet a deadline, or keep a launch on schedule. That urgency can influence our decisions, oftentimes without us even knowing.

We also explored Rushworth Kidder’s three moral reasoning lenses to help us work through an ethical dilemma:

  • Ends-based reasoning asks us to consider the likely benefits and harms of a decision for everyone affected.
  • Rules-based reasoning asks us to examine our duties and the principles we should apply consistently.
  • Care-based reasoning asks us to consider the needs of the people affected and how we would want to be treated in their situation.

Each lens on its own is insufficient. We should view an ethical dilemma through all three lenses to get a more complete picture of which path is the “right” one.

Our MBA students also read Ethical Breakdowns, by Max Bazerman and Ann Tenbrunsel, which examines how leaders can unintentionally encourage misconduct.

The students considered five barriers to ethical decisions: ill-conceived goals, motivated blindness, indirect blindness, the slippery slope, and overvaluing outcomes.

In the Sadhu case, we examined how the climbers divided responsibility. Different parties offered clothing, food, and other assistance. But nobody took responsibility for the final outcome, making sure he was safe before continuing on their journey. This illustrates what is often referred to as a diffusion of responsibility. When several people can help, each may assume someone else will take care of what remains. In an organization, that can happen as an issue moves between departments or passes from a manager to a vendor. But when we handoff a project, we don’t wash our hands of the ethical implications. Before transitioning ownership, we should all ask: Who is responsible for seeing this through?

We returned to Chip and Dan Heath’s WRAP framework to work through the Sadhu case. Students widened their options, identified assumptions to test, and considered the decision from a longer-term perspective. They also used the three moral reasoning lenses and discussed safeguards they could put in place if their plan proved wrong.

As McCoy wrote in the Parable of the Sadhu, reasonable people can disagree about what to do in a given dilemma. After all, that’s what makes it a dilemma. For this reason groups should have an agreed-upon framework for navigating those difficult moments. I hope the WRAP Framework, infused with the three lenses of moral reasoning, can help you and your team through some of your most challenging decisions.

Adam Stoverink PortraitDr. Adam Stoverink is the Executive Director of Walton MBA Programs and Associate Professor of Management in the Walton College of Business at the University of Arkansas. He holds a Ph.D. in Management from Mays Business School at Texas A&M University, an MBA from Chaifetz School of Business at Saint Louis University, and a Bachelor of Science in Management from the Trulaske College of Business at the University of Missouri.

His research examines phenomena related to leadership and high-performance work teams. He teaches leadership to graduate students and executive audiences in the Walton College. He is the recipient of the Wally Cordes Teaching Chair, the MBA Teacher of the Year Award, the Walton College Faculty Excellence in Teaching Award, and he was named a Teaching Fellow and inducted into the University of Arkansas Teaching Academy. His team in the Walton MBA Programs office was awarded the Walton College Outstanding Team Achievement Award.