University of Arkansas

Walton College

The Sam M. Walton College of Business

Why Are Supermarket Shelves Empty?

A mask-wearing woman shrugs her shoulders in front of empty supermarket shelves.
January 18, 2022  |  By Jason Miller, Andrew Balthrop

Share this via:

Media outlets such as CNN and Fox News have recently written about supermarket shelves being bare. Many consumers are concerned about this development, so we sought to provide a data-driven analysis of the problem. Synthesis and analysis of data from the Census Bureau, Bureau of Labor Statistics, and Bureau of Economic Analysis suggests three factors are at play.

Cause 1: Sales are elevated relative to employee headcounts.

To measure output per employee for food and beverage retailers, we calculated an index of real sales per employee, where real sales is calculated by deflating the Census Bureau’s not seasonally adjusted nominal sales data for food and beverage stores by the Bureau of Economic Analysis sales price deflator for food and beverage stores. Employment data comes from the Bureau of Labor Statistics not seasonally adjusted total employment for food and beverage stores. As shown in the first plot, real sales per employee were up substantially in 2021 relative to before the pandemic. For example, for July 2021 through December 2021, real sales per employee were over 10% greater than they were in 2019. This massive increase in physical unit sales per worker strains retailers’ efforts to keep shelves stocked.

Chart showing real sales per employee in food and beverage retailsince 28.

Cause 2: Inventories to sales are still below pre-pandemic levels.

Changes in a retail sector’s inventories to sales show how quickly they turnover their inventory. Food and beverage stores turn inventory particularly rapidly. But they have been doing this even more rapidly since the start of the pandemic. For example, from July 2021 through November 2021, inventories to sales were 9.8% and 9.3% below their 2018 and 2019 levels, respectively, for these same months of the year. This means that, not only are sales per employee up, but there are fewer items available in the backroom and at distribution centers relative to sales. This further compounds the problem of keeping shelves stocked.

Chart showing inventories to sales in food and beverage retail since 2018.

Cause 3: The Omicron variant is causing staffing woes.

The Omicron variant of the SARS-CoV-2 virus has resulted in skyrocketing infections. This has affected food and beverage stores’ abilities to maintain adequate staff.

The combination of higher sales per employee, fewer items relative to sales, and staffing problems are a “perfect storm” that is causing empty supermarket shelves. However, consumers can take solace in knowing that, once the Omicron variant passes, many health experts expect the SARS-CoV-2 virus to become endemic—like the seasonal flu—which should allow for a return to some degree of normalcy regarding supply chain matters. 

Post Authors:

Jason MillerJason Miller is an associate professor of supply chain management at Michigan State University's Eli Broad College of Business. He utilizes economic data from various government sources to develop insights for supply chain management practitioners.

 







Andrew BalthropAndrew Balthrop is a research associate within the Supply Chain Management Research Center at the University of Arkansas. His present research focus is on the interaction between the efficiency of freight transportation and government policy.  He has also done research in energy and environmental policy. He has published in the Journal of Operations Management, Journal of Business Logistics, Empirical Economics, and Energy Economics. Andrew received his Ph.D. in Economics from Georgia State University in 2012. 




Supply Chain Management Research Center

Walton College of Business

We engage industry, faculty, and students, serving as a trusted resource to exchange ideas, advance supply chain knowledge, and cultivate future industry leaders. Learn more...

Recent Posts

Student presentation at SCM Showcase

Event Highlight: Fall 22 SCM Student Showcase

Traditionally, the SCMRC concludes every semester with the SCM Student Showcase: a full day event featuring final presentations from the students within the Project Management Courses within the Walton Supply Chain Program. This course is a hallmark of the practice based learning that is embedded into the Walton SCM curriculum, engaging leading industry organizations in the classroom. Within this course, students tackle real world supply chain challenges, ideating, researching, and ultimately proposing solutions to the sponsoring company. The event - formerly known as Demo Day - featured poster project presentations as well as three student panel discussion showcasing the value of integrated industry within our program. Event Details are as follows: EVENT: SCM Student Showcase DATE: Friday, December 2, 2022 TIME: 9:00am – 1:00pm LOCATION: The Alumni House | Fayetteville, AR INVITE: Event exclusive for SCMRC members.

December 2, 2022 | By Nathan Bramwell

Healthcare white paper with a grayscale header image that shows a tablet and health information.

White Paper: Inflation and Healthcare Supply Chains

Inflation poses a particular challenge in the healthcare industry. Supply chain costs for the industry have risen faster than revenues, resulting in a squeeze for industry. Furthermore, disruptions in healthcare supply chains have resulted in higher cost increases than reported. JB Hunt Department of Supply Chain Management faculty discuss strategies for healthcare providers in the latest SCMRC white paper.

November 14, 2022

Podcast Image

SCMRC LEAD Podcast Season 2

Check out season 2 of the SCMRC LEAD Podcast, hosted by Mike Graen, Chair of the Retail Supply Chain Initiative (RSCI), a strategic partnership initiative of the SCMRC.

October 13, 2022

PLN Panel Discussion

Event Highlight: Summer PLN Event

The Summer 2022 SCMRC Peer Learning Event focused on labor issues within the supply chain. Kevin Kliesen of the St. Louis Federal Reserve Bank gave an assessment of overall macroeconomic conditions. Brian Fugate (University of Arkansas) engaged Kellie Black (ArcBest), Torin Martinez (P&G), and MaryEllen Kauffman (Walmart) in a panel discussion on managing workforce talent in the Post-COVID era.

October 11, 2022 | By Nathan Bramwell